Winchendon Courier · winchendoncourier.com
The Winchendon Courier
Serving the community since 1878
An Independent Community Newspaper
Alerts×
Opinion

EDITORIAL

Cet article est en cours de traduction ; le voici en anglais.

Listen · Read aloud; the words light up as you listen

Last Sunday, I led an Interfaith Thanksgiving service down in Petersham, an annual tradition for the Unitarian, Roman Catholic and Congregationalist churches there. I talked about the various meanings of our Thanksgiving holiday, which some people feel we shouldn't celebrate because that iconic (and largely apocryphal) "first Thanksgiving" didn't turn out too well for our local First Nations peoples. I see the situation from a much broader perspective, however. In my sermon, I said,

"Over the years, I've participated in Thanksgiving dinners with other people than my own family. A couple of them were especially memorable. In the 1990s, a friend of mine hosted a potluck "orphan's Thanksgiving" for about thirty people from many different classes and ethnic backgrounds who couldn't have Thanksgiving dinner that year with their families of origin. It was fascinating to see how many of the same holiday traditions this diverse group had in common--for example, the post-dinner walk around the neighborhood before dessert. It seemed like everybody's families did that. During that same period, I worked in a battered women's shelter. I usually covered the holidays in the shelter so my coworkers with families could have the day off. One year the shelter guests cooked the most magnificent multi-cultural feast I've ever seen, with Puerto Rican and Black American dishes alongside the turkey and stuffing. Even in the shelter, everyone wanted to celebrate Thanksgiving. I never heard any of the shelter guests, who were mostly low income, homeless, Black and Hispanic women and children, raise any questions about Thanksgiving's history.

"I don't believe most people who gather together for a big dinner on Thanksgiving are thinking much about the iconic image of Pilgrims and Indians happily eating together, that is now being challenged so severely. Our Thanksgiving holiday owes far more to ancient harvest celebrations going back thousands of years than to any 17th century interactions between early European immigrants and the local First Nations peoples. All of our ancestors held feasts to celebrate the harvest and prepare themselves psychologically for winter. The First Nations peoples had harvest celebrations for centuries before any White people arrived here. All European cultures had them. Similar celebrations are held in India, in Asian countries, and in African nations. Judaism has several holidays related to the harvest. In my earth-centered spiritual tradition, we have three harvest celebrations, in August, September, and November. If there's one thing we can all be thankful for, it's having enough food. The harvest celebration is unquestionably the closest thing to a universal human holiday on this earth, independent of any creed, religion or politics, rooted entirely in joy and gratitude for the earth's abundance and life itself.

"Where our American Thanksgiving holiday gets a little dodgier is the way it's been linked to certain Protestant Christian proclamations for "a day to give thanks," which usually involved a full day of prayer and worship followed by a feast day. The difficulty facing us is that these observances were often giving thanks for "victory over the enemy" in conflict or war. In the 1630s, for example, Massachusetts Governor William Bradford proclaimed a day of thanksgiving to commemorate the wholesale murder of hundreds of Pequot Native Americans, an action which we certainly do not see worthy of celebrating today. During and after World War II, Thanksgiving was linked to victory celebrations over the Japanese in terminology that we would now be extremely uncomfortable with.

"But is it fair to demonize all of Thanksgiving, a celebration of family, good fortune, and abundance, with these historical accretions, that really don't have anything to do with the core impulse for the holiday? I don't mean that to be a rhetorical question, but a genuine one. As people of good conscience, how do we address these issues of historical injustice, and how do we acknowledge, and reclaim, a celebration so ancient that it predates and transcends any individual nation's or culture's history?"

Worth thinking about, given the questions being raised about almost all our holidays--should we celebrate them, how should we celebrate them, what do they really mean, are they "under attack"...we Americans really can't agree on anything anymore, not even the holidays we all grew up with.

But one thing that's usually true about our arguments, no matter what the topic, is reductionism. We ignore all the complexities and depth of the issues at hand and turn everything into simplistic truisms that will fit in a meme or on a sign. Life doesn't work that way. Maybe if we stopped trying to reduce our debates to pep rally chants, we'd find that we don't have as many disagreements as we think.

Inanna Arthen

A name wrong in this story? Tell us
A figure wrong in this story? Tell us

Comments

0 so far
No comments yet. Be the first.

Sign up to comment

Your name shows with your comments; your email never does. We send one email — tap it and you are back here, signed in, ready to comment. No password.

Comments from signed-up readers appear at once. No links. Off-topic, spam and abusive comments are taken down. Already signed up? Sign in.